Zealot control of Jerusalem is confined to the inner court of the city and the Temple itself.
Outnumbered and isolated by Ananus' troops surrounding the Temple, Eleazar’s control of the Temple is seriously threatened from the winter of 67 to the spring of 68.
When John of Giscala enters Jerusalem, there is growing unrest.
Ananus, having incited the people to rise up against the Zealots, who are robbing the people and using the Temple of Jerusalem as their base of operations, begins to recruit for armed conflict.
The Zealots, learning of this, sally forth from the Temple quarter, attacking all in their way.
Ananus quickly organizes the people against them.
The skirmish begins with the belligerents throwing rocks at one another, then javelins, then finally hand-to-hand combat with swords ensues.
Eventually the Zealots retreat to the inner court of the Temple, and six thousand of Ananus’s men hold the first (outer) court.
According to Josephus, John of Giscala, who secretly seeks to rule Jerusalem, had cultivated a friendship with Ananus.
Suspected of being a spy, John is made to swear an "oath of goodwill" to Ananus and the people, after which Ananus sends John into the inner court, to speak with the Zealots on his behalf.
John desperately needed Eleazar's funds to supply his followers, and Eleazar requires the protection of John's large entourage to fend off Ananus.
John immediately turns coat, "as if his oath had been made to the zealots," telling them that they are in imminent danger, and cannot survive a siege.
He tells them that they have two options: 1) to surrender, in which case they would either face execution, vigilantism, or retribution for the "desperate things they had done"; or 2) to ask for outside assistance.
John tells the Zealots that Ananus had sent ambassadors to Vespasian to ask him to come take the city.
This in fact was not true, but persuades them that they cannot endure a siege without help.
The messengers manage to sneak out of the Temple and successfully deliver their message to the rulers of the Idumeans, who are greatly alarmed, and quickly raise an army of twenty thousand to march on Jerusalem, "in order to maintain the liberty of their metropolis."
Upon receiving word that twenty thousand Idumeans are marching on Jerusalem, ben Hanan orders the gates shut against them, and the walls guarded.
Jesus, one of the elder high priests, makes a speech from the walls, denouncing the Zealots as robbers and telling the Idumeans to throw down their arms.
Simon, son of Cathlas, one of the Idumean commanders, quiets the tumult of his own men and answers: "I can no longer wonder that the patrons of liberty are under custody in the temple, since there are those that shut the gates of our common city to their own nation, and at the same time are prepared to admit the Romans into it; nay, perhaps are disposed to crown the gates with garlands at their coming, while they speak to the Idumeans from their own towers, and enjoin them to throw down their arms which they have taken up for the preservation of its liberty...." (Josephus; The Jewish War, Book IV).
That night a thunderstorm blows over Jerusalem, and the Zealots sneak from the Temple to the gates, and cut the bars of the gates with saws, the sound masked by the sound of the wind and thunder.
They open the gates of Jerusalem to the Idumeans, who all upon the guards and make their way to the Temple.
They slaughter Ananus' forces there, killing him as well.
After freeing the Zealots from the Temple, they massacre the common people.
Eventually, after learning that Vespasian had never been contacted by Ananus, the Idumeans repent and leave the city.