The End of the Carolingian Civil War and the Treaty of Verdun (843)

The Carolignian civil war (840–843) finally concludes in August 843, when Louis the German and Charles the Bald unite against Lothair I, forcing him to accept the Treaty of Verdun. This treaty formally divides the Carolingian Empire into three distinct kingdoms, setting the political and cultural foundations of medieval Europe.

Territorial Divisions Under the Treaty

• Charles the Bald (West Francia) → Receives all lands west of a line following the Scheldt, Meuse, and Saône rivers, the eastern mountains of the Massif Central, and the lower Rhône River. This kingdom forms the basis of modern France.
• Louis the German (East Francia) → Receives the lands of the Germanic peoples, forming the core of what will later become Germany and the Holy Roman Empire.
• Lothair I (Middle Francia) → Retains the imperial title and receives the Middle Kingdom, a narrow and unstable realm stretching from the North Sea to Italy, including Lotharingia, Burgundy, and northern Italy.

The Rise of Feudal Lords and the Decline of Royal Power

• With the breakup of the empire, feudal lords and church leaders gain greater autonomy, as central authority weakens.
• Local rulers consolidate power, undermining royal control and paving the way for fragmentation and decentralization in all three kingdoms.
• The rise of powerful feudal lords leads to greater regionalism, weakening the ability of Carolingian rulers to enforce uniform policies.

The Impact on Jewish Communities

• The political fragmentation brought on by feudalism adversely affects the position of Jews in all three kingdoms.
• As local rulers and church officials gain power, Jewish communities face increasing restrictions, particularly in trade and public life.
• Whereas some Carolingian rulers had protected Jewish merchants for their economic contributions, feudal lords and bishops, influenced by growing religious intolerance, often impose harsh policies and limit Jewish economic activities.

Legacy of the Treaty of Verdun

• Marks the true beginning of medieval France and Germany, as the linguistic and cultural divide between West and East Francia solidifies.
• The Middle Kingdom proves politically unstable, leading to further divisions and setting the stage for centuries of territorial disputes between France and Germany.
• The decline of Carolingian imperial unity accelerates the rise of feudal states, shaping the power structures of medieval Europe.

The Treaty of Verdun (843) not only ends the Carolingian civil war but also reconfigures the political landscape of Europe, with far-reaching consequences for governance, society, and minority communities in the medieval period.

Consequences of the Rebellion

1. A Major Carolingian-Ottonian Conflict

   • This is not just a dynastic dispute but a major war between East and West Francia, with Louis IV trying to restore Carolingian rule over Lorraine and Otto fighting to maintain his authority.

2. A Fragile Balance of Power in Lorraine

   • The shifting allegiances in Lorraine highlight the region’s unstable position between East and West Francia, leading to continued territorial disputes for centuries.

3. Otto’s Rivalry with Louis IV Intensifies

   • With Louis IV actively supporting Otto’s enemies, the rivalry between the Carolingians and the Ottonians deepens, leading to further conflicts over Lotharingia and the fate of East Francia.

Conclusion: The Ottonian-Carolingian Struggle for Lorraine

The events of 939 illustrate the high stakes of the ongoing power struggle in East and West Francia, as rebellious nobles, exiled princes, and foreign kings maneuver for dominance. Though Otto manages to contain the rebellion, his war with Louis IV continues, reinforcing the fractured and volatile nature of early medieval Europe.

Upon his appointment as Duke of Lower Lorraine in 1012, Godfrey II of Verdun relinquished his previous holdings in Verdun, transferring them to his brother Frederick. This strategic decision was likely made to ensure continued family control over the city while allowing Godfrey to focus on the stabilization of Lower Lorraine.

Reasons for the Transfer

• Imperial Service: As Duke of Lower Lorraine, Godfrey II’s primary duty was to secure the imperial border and suppress feudal unrest in the region. By entrusting Verdun to his brother, he could fully commit to governing Lower Lorraine.
• Strengthening Family Influence: The House of Ardennes-Verdun already held substantial influence in Upper and Lower Lorraine. By keeping Verdun within the family, Godfrey ensured continued imperial support and local loyalty.
• Frederick’s Capability: Frederick, likely experienced in military and administrative matters, was a natural choice to assume authority over Verdun, a city of key economic and strategic importance.

Impact and Legacy

• The transfer allowed Godfrey II to consolidate his power in Lower Lorraine, while Verdun remained in trusted hands.
• The move reinforced the House of Ardennes-Verdun's hold over Lotharingia, ensuring that its members continued to dominate imperial politics in the region.
• Verdun’s control under Frederick further strengthened the imperial presence along the Meuse River, a key artery for trade and military movements between France and the Holy Roman Empire.

This redistribution of power within the Ardennes-Verdun family reflected the pragmatic feudal governance strategies of the period, ensuring that imperial loyalists held strategic strongholds while preventing internal conflicts.

The Hollanders' Raids and the Sack of Nijmegen and Verdun

• Dirk IV of Holland, emboldened by his victory over Henry III, raided deep into imperial territory, targeting key cities.
• His forces sacked Charlemagne’s palace at Nijmegen, an act meant to humiliate the emperor and undermine his authority in Lower Lorraine.
• The city of Verdun, an important ecclesiastical and commercial center, was burned, further exacerbating imperial instability.
• These raids demonstrated that Henry III’s authority in the Low Countries was not secure, and that anti-imperial forces were gaining momentum.

Godfrey the Bearded’s Penance and Rebuilding Efforts

• Amidst this ongoing chaos, Godfrey the Bearded—formerly the leader of the Lotharingian rebellion against Henry III—now sought to repair his relationship with the emperor.
• In a gesture of public penance, Godfrey took an active role in the reconstruction of Verdun, assisting in restoring the city and rebuilding the damages caused by Dirk IV’s forces.
• His penance and assistance in reconstruction marked a turning point in his relationship with Henry III, positioning him as a potential ally rather than an enemy.

Consequences and Political Shifts

• The Hollanders’ attacks shocked the imperial court, further exposing Henry III’s challenges in maintaining control over rebellious vassals.
• The destruction of Verdun and the desecration of Nijmegen signaled the deepening unrest in Lower Lorraine, requiring Henry III to continue military campaigns to reassert dominance.
• Godfrey’s public reconciliation with the empire weakened the anti-imperial alliance, isolating Dirk IV of Holland and Baldwin of Flanders, who continued to oppose Henry.

Though the Lotharingian conflict was far from over, Godfrey’s shift toward imperial reconciliation and his role in restoring Verdun reflected a changing political landscape, setting the stage for new alliances and further confrontations in the years ahead.

...Verdun, which together with Metz form the so-called Three Bishoprics.

...Verdun.

...Verdun near Lorraine), and ...

...Verdun.

The Prussian army now threatens Paris.