The convention that meets in Philadelphia, presided …
Years: 1787 - 1787
May
The convention that meets in Philadelphia, presided over by George Washington, is dominated by strong-government advocates.
Delegate Oliver Ellsworth of Connecticut argues that because the people cannot be trusted (as exemplified by Shays' Rebellion), the members of the federal House of Representatives should be chosen by state legislatures, not by popular vote.
The example of Shays' Rebellion may also have been influential in the addition of language to the constitution concerning the ability of states to manage domestic violence, and their ability to demand the return of individuals from other states for trial.
The rebellion also plays a role in the discussion of a number of the executives.
While mindful of tyranny, delegates of the Constitutional Convention think that the single executive will be more effective in responding to national disturbances.
Federalists cite the rebellion as an example of the confederation government's weaknesses, while opponents such as Elbridge Gerry think that a federal response to the rebellion would have been even worse than that of the state. (Gerry, a merchant speculator and Massachusetts delegate from Essex County, is one of the few convention delegates who will refuse to sign the new constitution, although his reasons for doing so do not stem from the rebellion.)
Delegate Oliver Ellsworth of Connecticut argues that because the people cannot be trusted (as exemplified by Shays' Rebellion), the members of the federal House of Representatives should be chosen by state legislatures, not by popular vote.
The example of Shays' Rebellion may also have been influential in the addition of language to the constitution concerning the ability of states to manage domestic violence, and their ability to demand the return of individuals from other states for trial.
The rebellion also plays a role in the discussion of a number of the executives.
While mindful of tyranny, delegates of the Constitutional Convention think that the single executive will be more effective in responding to national disturbances.
Federalists cite the rebellion as an example of the confederation government's weaknesses, while opponents such as Elbridge Gerry think that a federal response to the rebellion would have been even worse than that of the state. (Gerry, a merchant speculator and Massachusetts delegate from Essex County, is one of the few convention delegates who will refuse to sign the new constitution, although his reasons for doing so do not stem from the rebellion.)
Locations
People
Groups
- Pennsylvania, Commonwealth of (U.S.A.)
- Connecticut, State of (U.S.A.)
- United States of America (US, USA) (Philadelphia PA)
- Massachusetts, Commonwealth of (U.S.A.)
