The Numantians themselves fight on, forcing the surrender, in 137 BCE, of a twenty thousand-man Roman consular army led by Gaius Hostilius Mancinus, Roman consul for this year, who allegedly put out his fires and tried to flee by night before being surrounded and forced to make peace.
According to Plutarch, Tiberius Gracchus was instrumental in bringing about the peace and saving twenty thousand Roman soldiers.
He returns home something of a hero, but Mancinus is put on trial by the Senate, which refuses to accept the treaty.
While Gracchus and other lieutenants are saved by Scipio Africanus Minor, the Senate decrees that Mancinus be handed over to the Numantines, as some twenty Roman commanders were handed over to the Samnites after the defeat at Caudine Forks in 321 BCE.
Plutarch does not relate Mancinus' further fate; Appian, however, noted that he was taken to Spain and handed over naked to the Numantines, but that they refused to accept him.
The Roman Senate, however, refuses to acknowledge defeat and elects to continue the struggle.